Hands up if you’re part of a fandom, and if you watch, listen and read eagerly as your favourite stories unfold. Also put your hands up if you’ve ever finished a season or series of something, and held onto an idea, a possibility, an alternative to what happened. Keep your hands up if you’ve read and/or written fanfiction, taken guesses at what might come next, processed something interesting or troubling from the original, and wanted badly to see it captured in words and shared with other fans to get their perspectives.
I also geek out over my favourites and spend time between iterations anticipating what comes next, and I read fanfic once in a while too. Fanfic is creative, it inspires people to read and write, and it encourages thinkers to play the “what if” game. This last part is key.
It recently occurred to me that my occupation (I’m a philosopher) is built on similar practices. I’d go so far as to say that to do philosophy is to engage in the same stream of thought as fanfic. Philosophers are, in a strange way, just a different brand of fanfiction creators.
To be a fanfic creator, or to be a philosopher, is to engage in an ongoing game of what comes next. Fanfic speculates about unexplored character arcs, plot twists, behind the scenes details, and alternate universes. A philosopher goes through the same mental aerobics, but with things like truth, beauty, justice, and love. In both cases, someone gets an idea in their head, and follows it down a series of rabbit holes to see where it ends up.
Both philosophers and fanfic creators take things in one direction, and then another. Sometimes this practice bears fruit, and sometimes it leads to dead ends. We both imagine a universe in which things could have gone or might still go differently. We piece together how life might follow, how people might change, and how our outlook on everything might grow and shift. Sometimes it’s something frivolous, and sometimes it’s almost prophetic, but it always presents us with a new lens through which to examine our reality. Sometimes it yields new ideas and questions, and sometimes it falls flat. Sometimes it deserves to fall flat.
What does it take to be a philosopher or a fanfic creator? Creativity, obviously. An open mind, hopefully. It requires the guts to put an idea out there, and the patience and humility to sit through criticism and feedback (I’m still working on this last one). In both pursuits, there are likes, shares, follows, and trolls. In both pursuits, sometimes you need to go back to the beginning, because the next season comes out or you hear of potential spoilers or new details.
If philosophy is really just a form of fanfic, then what is the thing about which philosophers are fan-ing? I guess we’re fans of existence, of reason and logic, and of meaning. We geek out over dialogue and debate. Like a fanfic creator, we are nothing if not passionate about the questions we ask and the ideas we explore. We can’t seem to leave them alone, to get them out of our heads, to stop thinking and talking about them. Like any fanfic creator who chooses to share their work, we hope that there’s something useful in it, and that someone else, somewhere else, shares our spark.